UPDATE--added authors' names
I reviewed some best-of-2007 lists published by newspapers and magazines, specifically the ones that didn't go on and on, and tabulated which books appeared on more than two lists. Here, dear reader, are the results. I would advise caution. I watched a couple of stupefying independent films last year because they had the highest average reviews on Metacritic. In fact, I'm quite sure I'm going to avoid the Ann Pratchett book below.
These books appeared on five lists:
The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao by Junot Díaz
Tree of Smoke: A Novel by Denis Johnson
Four lists:
On Chesil Beach: A Novel by Ian McEwan
The Savage Detectives: A Novel by Roberto Bolano
And three lists:
Bridge of Sighs by Richard Russo
Lost City Radio by Daniel Alarcon
Mister Pip by Lloyd Jones
Run by Ann Patchett
The Septembers of Shiraz by Dalia Sofer
The Shadow Catcher: A Novel by Marianne Wiggins
The Yiddish Policemen's Union: A Novel by Michael Chabon
Then We Came to the End: A Novel by Joshua Ferris
If you're curious, the periodicals I reviewed were the Christian Science Monitor, the Washington Post (which cheated and published two such lists), the LA Times, the NY Times, BookSense, the Economist, Entertainment Weekly, The San Francisco Chronicle, and the Seattle Times.